Hard landing watch: recent data wrap
Simon Ward
1 Comment
October flash PMI results for major developed economies imply little change in the global composite PMI new orders index (released 6 November). The current index level is 1 standard deviation below the long-run average. Weakening real narrow money momentum suggests a further decline through end-Q1 2024 – see previous post.
What to make of the US GDP surge of 4.9% annualised in Q3? Likely temporary factors contributed (strong government spending, a rebound in stockbuilding). National accounts numbers have jarred with talk of economic strength since end-2021: GDP rose at an annualised rate of 1.2% over the six quarters to Q2 2023, with growth of the alternative income measure at just 0.2%. The Q3 GDP number may represent a statistical catch-up (an income estimate will be released next month).
Retail sales / consumption strength is difficult to reconcile with the BEA’s near real-time data on card spending – see chart 1. Similarly, the GDP number appears out of line with PMIs and moderate Q3 growth in private aggregate hours worked (1.7% annualised).
Chart 1
Chinese Q3 GDP growth also surprised to the upside but is easier to explain – as payback for a weak Q2. The two-quarter rate of change fell again – chart 2. A decline in six-month real narrow money momentum during Q3 suggests a further slowdown into early 2024.
Chart 2
Verdict: PMIs consistent with soft or hard landing; US GDP strength temporary / erratic; China losing momentum.
View Printer Friendly Version
Email Article to Friend
Reader Comments (1)
Simon, it would be interesting to hear the monetarist response to the charge that monetarism 'failed' in the 80s. Bootle raised this yesterday in the Telegraph.