Entries from January 5, 2014 - January 11, 2014
Eurozone deflation worries overblown: update
Commentators continue to speculate that the Eurozone will enter a deflationary scenario in which household and business expectations of falling prices cause spending to be deferred. Such worries are not supported by EU Commission December consumer and business surveys.
The first chart shows annual CPI inflation and an expectations indicator* derived from the consumer survey. The indicator has been stable recently at close to its historical average. The current level is consistent with the ECB’s target of “inflation rates below, but close to, 2%”.
Price-raising plans in business surveys covering industry, construction, services and retailing are similarly normal and little changed from a year ago.
The consumer inflation expectations indicator remains positive even in Italy and Spain – second chart.
Annual CPI inflation slipped back to 0.8% in December, though remains above October’s 0.7%. A previous post argued that weakness reflects disastrously restrictive monetary policy in 2011, when the ECB hiked rates despite money supply stagnation. The policy reversal under President Draghi succeeded in reviving the key M1 measure in 2012-13, with economic activity now responding and inflation likely to follow later in 2014 – assuming no further exchange rate strength. Current monetary trends suggest that deflation risks are receding even in the periphery – see post last week.
*The indicator is the sum of the net percentages of consumers reporting higher prices over the last 12 months and expecting a faster increase over the coming 12 months.
Global cyclical risks are rising
Global growth picked up during 2013, ending the year at a solid pace. This strength should carry over into early 2014 but momentum is likely to wane as the year progresses. The global economy may be entering the late stage of the cycle, characterised by rising capacity constraints, increased inflationary pressure and tightening liquidity.
Monetary trends predicted recent economic improvement. A year ago, global* real (i.e. inflation-adjusted) money supply growth was strong and higher than output expansion. This signalled that economic prospects were brightening and there was “excess” liquidity available to boost financial markets. Global industrial production grew by 5% annualised in the six months to November 2013, up from just 1% a year earlier. Equities, of course, have performed strongly.
Current monetary signals are less favourable. Global real money growth is still respectable but has declined since spring 2013. With economies strengthening, it has fallen beneath output expansion. This suggest that economic momentum is close to a peak, while markets no longer enjoy a liquidity tailwind.
Most forecasters and investors expect current strength to be sustained. The IMF recently signalled increased optimism, raising its 2014 growth projections for the US and Japan. According to Merrill Lynch, three-quarters of global fund managers judge the economy to be in the early or middle part of the cycle, implying that the upswing has several more years to run. This view is questionable on numerous grounds.
First, the cycle already looks mature by historical standards. Global industrial output has risen by 30% since February 2009 and is 12% above its prior peak – see first chart. The upswing has lasted 58 months versus an average duration of 78 months for the previous four trough-to-peak output rises. If the current cycle were to match the average, another recession would begin in 2015.
Secondly, stronger growth is running into supply-side constraints. In the US, the Institute for Supply Management business survey indicates that the economy-wide operating rate is above average – at odds with claims that there is still a large “negative output gap”. Firms globally are finding it difficult to recruit skilled labour: skill shortages are at their most acute since 2007, at the end of the last cycle, according to the world business survey conducted by Germany’s Ifo Institute – second chart.
Thirdly, there are signs that inflationary pressure is reviving in response to capacity tightening. Global inflation was broadly stable in 2013, with falls in strong currency areas – in particular, the Eurozone – offset by rises in Japan and elsewhere. Business price expectations in the Ifo world survey rose notably in late 2013, to their strongest since spring 2011 – third chart. Commodity prices have firmed recently.
Central banks are trying to extend the cycle by promising to defer official interest rate increases until after inflation rises. Liquidity conditions, however, tighten endogenously at the end of a cycle as stronger activity and price gains push up longer-term yields and cause the gap between real money and output expansion to close. This process is under way. Central banks usually lag market-driven liquidity tightening, often magnifying its effect at the wrong time. The current cycle is unlikely to be different.
Rather than loose policy, the best hope of extending the cycle is a surge in business investment that boosts supply capacity and defers higher inflation. Capital spending intentions have firmed but are not signalling a major shift towards expansion. Continued business reluctance to increase capacity, ironically, probably partly reflects additional uncertainty created by central banks’ “monetary activism”.
2013 was a better year for financial markets than main street. The reverse may be true in 2014, as forward-looking markets begin to anticipate more difficult economic conditions in 2015.
*”Global” figures quoted refer to the G7 major countries and seven large emerging economies (the “E7”).
An abridged version of this article appeared in today's City AM.