Entries from October 1, 2007 - October 31, 2007
Rock loan still climbing
"Other assets" on the Bank of England’s balance sheet rose by a further £2.3 billion in the week to Wednesday 10th October, bringing the total increase since the run on Northern Rock started to £12.9 billion. This is the best available estimate of the extent of the Bank’s support to the troubled mortgage lender.
The weekly increase has slowed from £2.9 billion in the week to 3rd October and £4.9 billion in the prior week. However, the continuing erosion of Northern Rock’s funding base explains the Government’s decision this week to extend its guarantee to new retail deposits.
The Bank of England’s injection of funds into Northern Rock has contributed to an easing of money market conditions in recent weeks. The banking system's reserves at the Bank rose from £19.8 billion on Wednesday 12th September, just before the run on the mortgage bank, to £29.0 billion on 19th September and £29.2 billion on 26th September before falling back to £26.8 billion on 3rd October and £20.8 billion this week. Three-month interbank interest rates fell from 6.90% to 6.27% over the same period. Northern Rock has used the funds advanced by the Bank at a penalty rate to repay its retail depositors and other creditors. (A small portion will also have been needed to fund mortgage commitments.) Rather than stash cash under the mattress, these customers have mostly redeposited their savings with other banks and building societies, which have thereby enjoyed an infusion of liquidity without having to pay the Bank's penalty rate for emergency borrowing. This Northern Rock liquidity effect helps to explain why banks have spurned the Bank of England's offer to supply them with additional three-month funds based on looser collateral requirements but at an interest rate at least 1% above Bank rate. In effect, Northern Rock's shareholders have paid the penalty demanded by the Bank to supply the banking system as a whole with greater liquidity. More controversially, it could be argued that the current structure of incentives has created another form of "moral hazard": by refusing to lend to Northern Rock, other banks have forced the Bank to supply additional liquidity, which they have been able to access at non-penalty rates.
Is takeover activity reviving?
I am a fan of Trim Tabs, a California-based research firm that compiles and analyses data on equity market flows. Trim Tabs have remained bullish on US stocks partly because of a big pick-up in share buy-backs during the recent correction. This resulted in equity market “float” – the number of shares outstanding – continuing to contract despite a slump in cash takeovers; with supply falling, stock prices were supported. Strong buy-backs also suggested corporate insiders were sanguine about profits and saw value in their shares.
Buy-back announcements often accompany earnings releases so the trend over the forthcoming reporting season should be monitored closely. However, Trim Tabs are now pointing to another potentially bullish development – a revival in cash takeover bids. The aggregate value of new cash deals surged to $11.8 billion last week – the highest since July. Normalising credit markets could help to sustain this pick-up, providing fuel for the next leg up in stocks.
UK Pre-Budget Report: initial impressions
The Pre-Budget Report looks insignificant in macroeconomic terms but may deliver short-term political gains, with measures to gather extra revenues from the private equity industry and non-domiciles used to fund a new low capital gains tax rate of 18% and transferable inheritance tax allowances for couples.
As already leaked, the Treasury has revised down its GDP growth forecast for 2008 from 2.5-3.0% to 2.0-2.5%. This forced the Chancellor to push back projected improvement in the public finances but the current budget still miraculously returns to surplus in 2009-10. Risks remain high though: the forecast depends on an optimistic-looking growth rebound in 2009 as well as adherence to restrictive public spending plans and a further rise in the revenue share of GDP.
The centre-piece of the Report was capital gains tax reform, which is projected to raise £900 million per annum by 2010-11 – the abolition of taper relief enjoyed by private equity firms and other holders of “business assets” more than offsets the cost of lowering the headline rate to 18%. The Chancellor plans to use this cash together with an extra £500 million to be garnered from “non-doms” to fund an effective increase in inheritance tax allowances for couples to £600,000, costed at £1.4 billion by 2010-11.
The capital gains tax changes represent a welcome simplification although there is a risk that some private equity activity will now shift offshore. The main criticism of its Report is its failure to provide a fiscal cushion against unforeseen economic deterioration. With an election delayed until 2009 or 2010, there was a case for tightening fiscal policy now to allow more room for manoeuvre nearer polling day. Politically astute? Time will tell.

The new single 18% capital gains tax rate ought to benefit the stock market and may favour "growth" over "value". Higher-rate tax-payers now have a major incentive to receive return in the form of capital gain rather than income. This should encourage a shift away from cash and bond-type investments towards stocks, particularly lower-yielding growth companies. Meanwhile the abolition of taper relief implies there is no longer any reason to accumulate wealth in the form of illiquid "business assets" as opposed to liquid equities.
Eurozone gloom deepening
The consensus view is that downside economic risks are greater in the US than the Eurozone. I am sceptical.
Monetary policy should be a much bigger drag in Euroland. After last month's cut, the Fed funds target rate is unchanged from 18 months ago. The ECB has hiked its repo rate by 150 b.p. over the same period. Credit conditions look at least as restrictive as in the US: according to the latest ECB survey, a net 31% of banks tightened standards on corporate lending in the third quarter – the highest since Q2 2003.
The chart shows the OECD’s leading indicator indices, designed to predict industrial activity about six months ahead. The US index has picked up since the spring, though slipped back recently. By contrast, the Eurozone index has been weakening steadily and now suggests industrial stagnation. Within the region the weakest country indices are Italy and Spain.
If the indices are correct, forecasts of further Fed rate cuts while the ECB stands pat look questionable. Any revision to expectations could hurt the euro.
US income growth supporting consumption
Amazingly, the US Treasury publishes daily figures on withheld income and employment taxes (similar to UK pay-as-you-earn taxes). In theory, these receipts should be an excellent real-time indicator of employee incomes, which account for about one-half of GDP. Even better, the information is ignored by most economists.
The daily figures are noisy and need to be smoothed and adjusted for seasonal variation. As the chart shows, the resulting series has been a good guide to the broad trend in the economy in recent years, signalling the 2001 recession, the slow recovery of 2002-03 and subsequent acceleration.
Withheld taxes softened during the first half of 2007 but have picked up more recently, with unsmoothed September receipts particularly strong. This was a good tip-off that September employment numbers would be respectable – non-farm payrolls rose by 110,000 while August’s change was revised from down 4,000 to up 89,000.
The full effects of the “credit crunch” have yet to be felt but favourable income trends should help to cushion economic weakness.
Rocky horror update
“Other assets” on the Bank of England’s balance sheet – the category that includes the Bank’s “lender of last resort” support to Northern Rock – rose by a further £2.9 billion in the week to Wednesday 3rd October following a £4.9 billion gain in the previous week. “Other assets” have now increased by £10.7 billion since 12th September, just before the run on the troubled mortgage lender.
“Other assets” is a residual category covering a range of Bank activities and showed limited variation before the Northern Rock crisis – see chart below. It is possible that some of these activities have contributed to the recent surge but the bulk of the increase is likely to reflect lending to the mortgage bank.
There is speculation that the Bank has been providing covert support to other institutions facing funding difficulties but this would be at odds with recent evidence from Mervyn King, the Bank’s governor, to the Treasury Select Committee. In this he claimed that the Market Abuses Directive of 2005 prevented the Bank from conducting covert “lender of last resort” operations.
The estimated £10 billion plus size of the Northern Rock loan compares with the Bank of England’s capital and reserves of £1.9 billion at 28th February, according to its latest annual report. The Bank’s capital arguably needs to be increased if it is to be expected to conduct emergency operations on the present scale.